Best Cheap Beer
Published on By Gina Briles
While there are plenty of microbreweries pumping out delicious craft beer, sometimes you just want a brew that is cheap and tasty. Check out: 17 Cheap Beers that Locals Love
What's the most popular craft beer in your state? To find out here: The Best Selling Craft Beer in Every State
Drink responsibly and seasonally -- check out Best Cheap Beers for Fall: 10 Craft Brews to Toast the Season
Thinking about stocking up on some cases? See why you shouldn't buy beer in bulk here: 20 Items You Should Avoid Buying in Bulk
Full Sail IPA Review
From $7 Best
Of the four craft beers and five American-style lagers we served a panel of volunteers in a blind taste test, Full Sail IPA earned the No. 2 spot on the list of best budget brews. It is also the cheapest of the craft beers sampled. We shelled out the same amount for a six-pack of Full Sail ($6.99) as we did for a six-pack of Budweiser ($6.99 on sale; regular price $8.49). There was a cost-per-ounce difference, however, given that Budweiser came in 16-ounce cans, making it about 7 cents an ounce on sale (9 cents an ounce at regular price). Full Sail is packaged in the more standard 12-ounce bottle size, for a cost of just under 10 cents an ounce.
Where to buy
New Belgium Fat Tire Review
From $10 Best
When consumers think of cheap beer, upmarket craft selections are probably not what come to mind. Affordable craft brews typically run $3 to $4 more for a six-pack than standard American lagers. New Belgium Fat Tire isn't the cheapest libation on the shelf, but our 2016 blind taste test of this and three other craft beers and five American-style lagers determined that it's a pretty darned good value for those who crave the complex flavor profile that craft beers tend to provide.
Where to buy
Miller High Life Review
From $7.50 Good
In a beer taste test hosted by Cheapism a few years ago, 13 participants took a marked dislike to Miller High Life. They described the lager variously as "soapy" and "flat," as well as "unpleasant and frothy." With a different group of drinkers in 2016, opinions were more favorable; the general consensus on the flavor was "sweet" and "crisp." The most recent review panel, consisting of seven beer enthusiasts, preferred the Miller beer to the three other American-produced lagers they tried, moving Miller High Life into a category of beers we can recommend rather than relegating it to the bottom of the barrel, where it landed in the first competitive tasting round.
Where to buy
Modelo Especial Review
From $8 Good
A lager imported from Mexico, Modelo Especial found favor with our 2016 review panel. They preferred it over the four American-produced lagers we sampled in a blind taste-off but ranked it behind the four craft beers tested. Lager fans called it "light" and "clean," and appreciated the "bubbly" consistency. One among the seven in the tasting group said the "first sip hits with a strong taste" that some described as "skunky." Others declared that flavor to be "sour." Panelists, unaware what brands they were tasting, wondered aloud if this was Heineken or a "Mexican beer," but opined that Heineken and Corona were better. This brew's ABV is 4.5 percent.
Where to buy
Pabst Blue Ribbon Review
From $7.50 Think Twice
Pabst Blue Ribbon is an American lager that continues to surprise us. The first time Cheapism conducted a taste test that included 19 inexpensive beers, PBR took top billing against eight other inexpensive lagers. It corralled drinkers' admiration with a "mild," "drinkable" flavor and "good balance." That group of 13 called PBR "a little hoppy" and took exception to the somewhat "flat aftertaste." One panelist announced it was the "first drinkable" beer she had tasted that evening.
Where to buy
From $8.50 Think Twice
When asked to assess Budweiser's flavor, Cheapism's 2016 review panel protested, saying there wasn't any. These seven tasters chose descriptors such as "flat," "watery," and "low alcohol" to characterize the taste despite the fact that Budweiser is a beer with an ABV of 5 percent. One snarky panelist remarked, "This is the keg the morning after the party." Another, who seemed to prefer mainstream lagers to craft brews, said it "didn't taste like beer." In fact, Budweiser, one of the first American lagers, was liked less than four other mass-produced lagers and four craft brews our tasting group sampled. It bested only one: Pabst Blue Ribbon. In a blind tasting we organized a few years ago, Budweiser fared better, falling in the mid-range of the nine brands in its class that 13 volunteers rated.
We wondered, would online Budweiser reviews paint a different picture? In a word, no. At RateBeer, an aggregate of nearly 4,000 consumer reviews yielded a weighted average score (assessing aroma, taste, palate, and appearance) of only 1.45 out of 5. Posts reveal that many drinkers find the beer unremarkable and light on taste. More than 1,500 reviews at BeerAdvocate assign Budweiser a dismal ranking of 58 out of 100, calling it "awful." Many lament that it's watery, as did our 2016 tasting panel, while others remark on what they perceive as a grassy taste and excessive carbonation level.
Pricewise, this is a mid-range beer. We grabbed a six-pack of 16-ounce cans for $6.99 with a supermarket club card, although the pack would have set us back $8.49 at regular price.
Budweiser was first brewed commercially in 1876 and remains a popular Anheuser-Busch offering to this day. The brewing process features a blend of barley, malts, and rice, in addition to aroma hops. Over the years this lager bandied about the nickname "King of Beers," but our Budweiser review found that the crown has tarnished. All in all, Budweiser seems more a pauper's beer than the American nobility it lays claim to.
Where to buy
Over the past several years, scores of new varieties of beer have flooded the shelves, with the marketplace becoming both wider and more specialized. Craft beers are competing head-to-head with the traditional standbys and altering the perception of what constitutes an acceptable price; $15 for a six-pack is now fairly commonplace. The question is, must an avid beer drinker keen on a fresh, full taste really shell out that kind of cash? Cheapism has consulted online ratings and reviews and conducted two comparative samplings in a continuing quest to identify the best cheap suds, whether old-school American-style lagers or their craftier contemporaries. This year, our panelists tasted nine popular beers in a blind test to help guide consumers to high-quality brews at budget prices.
Cheap Beer Taste Test 2016
Beer, cheap or not, has a long-standing history of quenching human thirst. Dating back centuries, fermented brews have nourished Pharaohs, inspired Egyptian philosophers, and funded monasteries. Even today, the significance of sharing a drink at celebrations or social gatherings remains. But are frugal hosts doomed to pass around the stuff they consumed in their salad days?
In Cheapism's first beer taste test, in 2013, the sample of 19 beers was limited to brands costing less than $7 for a six-pack. This time we raised both our price point and our expectations. In other words, we included more inexpensive craft brews and moved away from some homogeneous brands that seem better suited for chugging than savoring. With a price cap of $10 for six 12-ounce bottles or cans, we put to the test five mass-produced American-style lagers and four widely distributed craft brews in a variety of styles.
The contenders: Budweiser ($8.50), Miller High Life ($7.50), Modelo Especial ($8), Pabst Blue Ribbon ($7.50), Rolling Rock ($5.50), Full Sail IPA ($7), New Belgium Fat Tire ($10), Samuel Adams Boston Lager ($10), and Sierra Nevada Pale Ale ($10). Budweiser, Miller High Life, and PBR were sold in 16-ounce cans; the rest in 12-ounce bottles. We chilled the beers to the same temperature for the same amount of time and presented them to a panel of seven self-proclaimed beer drinkers, masking the labels with paper bag wrapping. Panelists evaluated each beer with attention to qualities such as flavor, nose, mouth feel, appearance, and drinkability and noted their favorite and least favorite brews.
The final tallies were somewhat expected and somewhat surprising. Craft beers dominated our tasters' top picks, lending some credence to recent drinking trends. And some brews that tanked in our previous taste test bubbled to the top this time -- and vice versa.
New Belgium Fat Tire, an amber ale, was deemed the most universally palate-pleasing for its "crisp, light mouth feel" and smooth flavor. Although more testers declared the cheaper Full Sail IPA their favorite quaff, it was divisive, turning off some with its "strong taste" and "bitterness that hangs in your mouth." (IPAs tend to be polarizing in general, but they account for more than a quarter of the craft beer market, and expert reviews identified this one as only mildly hoppy.) For consumers who prefer lighter, milder, easy-drinking beer, Modelo Especial and Miller High Life were the top-scoring American-style lagers, despite trailing all four craft beers. Among the least popular brews was Budweiser, which our drinkers deemed "flat" and "watery," and Pabst Blue Ribbon was the biggest loser. Tasters called it "bitter," "generic," and fit for a "college keg party."
PBR fared far better in our earlier taste test, laying claim to best American lager. Anheuser-Busch's Natural Ice ($16.50 for a 30-pack) followed a step behind with "bright" flavor and drinkability. Among the top performers, the closest thing to craft beer was Costco's "handcrafted" Kirkland Signature beers ($19 for a sampler pack of 24 bottles). The IPA won the most fans with its "bitter" but "floral" notes, and the German-style lager turned heads with its "smooth," "sweet" flavor.
This year we tried to get away from "college beer," although not altogether. Inevitably, some breweries were bypassed despite their brands' ubiquity; stalwarts such as Stroh's, Schlitz, Keystone, and Milwaukee's Best were not included in this limited test. We also skipped over light beers, which the first panel found unremarkable and nearly indistinguishable. Kirkland Signature brews were excluded from this year's tasting in favor of brands widely available with no membership fee, but for Costco members, and non-members in select states, the warehouse club's house-brand beers are well worth a try.
While the pricier craft beers in this year's blind tasting scored better than the cheaper lagers, it shouldn't be taken as gospel that a higher price tag equates to a higher ranking -- or a better beer-drinking experience. Value is driven by both cost and personal taste. The cheapest lager may not be a good value for the drinker who demands strong flavor. Conversely, for someone who wants a light beer that goes down quickly, it may not be worth spending extra money on a higher-rated craft brew. We took this into account by comparing cost per ounce and by noting beers that stood out for a disparity in cost versus likability.
Full Sail IPA, which came in second out of the nine brews tested, costs 4 cents an ounce less than the other craft beers, and even less than the American-style lager Modelo Especial (by 1 cent an ounce). In the first competitive round, some of the 13 volunteers voiced a preference for craft brews and particular mainstream beers before tasting commenced. In the end, they were stunned to learn they had rated Costco's Kirkland Signature beers higher than their professed, and pricier, favorites.
Standard American-Style Lager.Domestically produced American lagers dominate the budget beer market, largely due to their easy drinkability. The lagers in this year's blind tasting came from big-name producers Anheuser-Busch (Budweiser and Rolling Rock), Miller Brewing Co., and Pabst Brewing Co. and also included Modelo Especial, imported from Mexico. Among our panel, the emerging consensus was that these brews were interchangeable. Both beer-tasting sessions produced comments such as, "these all taste the same" and "I can't tell the difference." When asked to focus on the subtleties of each sample, however, the panelists drew some distinctions.
Modelo Especial slightly outranked Miller High Life to become 2016's top-rated lager in terms of taste, although the lead was narrow. One panelist called Miller High Life their favorite of the bunch and no one scored it least favorite, while a different panelist deemed Modelo Especial least favorite and no one chose this brand as a favorite. Add to this a price disparity of 3 cents an ounce (8 cents for Miller High Life compared with 11 cents for Modelo Especial), and Miller High Life begins to look like the better bargain -- depending on taste preferences, of course. Our discerning beer drinkers called Miller High Life "light," "sweet," and "crisp." One taster opined that it was a good choice for a "long round of golf," while another said he'd use it to boil brats. Modelo Especial turned off one panelist with a taste he compared to "cough medicine," but others seemed satisfied with the "clean," "effervescent" feel and flavor of this "basic picnic chug" -- sufficient to merit a recommendation as a "good" cheap beer.
On the opposite end of the drinkability spectrum sat Pabst Blue Ribbon, which failed to impress our 2016 tasting crew despite having scored a "best" in the earlier budget beer taste-off. This time it elicited comments such as "generic," "meh," and "there's nothing there." One disgruntled drinker surmised that "they only ask $1 a cup at this party." Budweiser likewise failed to deliver on taste, according to our enthusiasts. After sipping this popular beer, reactions ranged from "no flavor" to "why bother?" One panelist said, "This wouldn't encourage me to get another round." Rolling Rock languished in the middle of the pack. Tasters exhibited little enthusiasm for this "lawn-mowing beer" with its "empty calories," and agreed it would be best consumed "super cold" on a hot day.
Craft Beer.Consumers shopping for suds on a budget probably don't wander over to the craft beer section of the store too often. There's no getting around the fact that craft beers generally cost more than standard American lager. But for any beer drinker who can't be reconciled to the milder-tasting alternatives, or is keen to rotate affordable craft brews into the fridge, our beer tasting sessions uncovered several decent and cheap options.
Our informal blind tasting included brews from Samuel Adams, New Belgium, Sierra Nevada, and Full Sail. On the whole, our beer tasters preferred the more complex, hoppier flavors of these beers to the lighter taste of the lagers.
New Belgium Fat Tire edged out Full Sail IPA to win the gold overall. Tasters unanimously warmed to Fat Tire's "nutty," "chocolate" notes and savored the "malty nose" and "smooth finish." More panelists deemed Full Sail IPA their favorite for its hints of fruit and "complex," "hoppy and bitter" flavor, but others couldn't stomach the "strong taste," which pulled down the beer's overall rating.
Still, Full Sail IPA impressed us with its comparatively low price -- 10 cents an ounce compared with 14 cents for the other craft beers in the sample. For those who appreciate the hoppy bitterness of an IPA (a taste admittedly not for everyone), Full Sail is a respectable and reasonable buy. The brand markets an award-winning amber ale, as well.
Boston Lager took third place owing to its "mild," "medium flavor" and "extended finish." Some appreciated the aftertaste, calling it "bitter" but "not too bitter," although some others found it too "sour" for their liking. As with Full Sail IPA, this brew garnered more favorite votes than Fat Tire, but its overall score was marred by some negative feedback. The least-praised craft beer we tested, Sierra Nevada Pale Ale, found approval with its "bright," "citrusy flavor" but literally ended on a sour note, with a "flat," "vinegar aftertaste."
Light Beer.Excluded from this year's taste test, the light beers sampled in the original session (sold in six-packs of 16-ounce cans) garnered lukewarm appraisals, with descriptors such as "flat," "bland," and "watery." Tasters expressed a tad more enthusiasm for Miller Lite ($8) than Coors Light ($6), Bud Light ($6), and Busch Light ($6.60). Miller Lite trumped the three other low-calorie contenders with a "more sophisticated taste" and "subtle bitterness that is interesting." Bud Light, one of the more popular light American lagers, garnered the fewest "favorite" votes from our first panel.
All the light beers were considered nearly identical in appearance and flavor (or lack thereof). When commenting on taste, more than one panelist dittoed remarks from one beer to the next, and few descriptive notes were unique to any one product. One beer reviewer said the light beers looked like "water with a touch of Tang or Gatorade." The panel concluded that Miller Lite showed the deepest color of the four. And although they picked Miller Lite over the others for having the "boldest taste" of the bunch, it was a bit pricier than the competition, and the differences were barely noticeable.
Additional Products We Considered
Samuel Adams Boston Lager Review
Samuel Adams Boston Lager debuted in 1985, and, according to some, began a craft beer revolution in the United States. Opinions are mixed as to whether or not Boston Lager qualifies as a craft beer, however. Depending on whom you ask, it is either a still-innovative and wildly successful craft product or a former craft brand, now too insulated by the behemoth size of parent Boston Brewing Co. to be relevant or cutting-edge. Regardless, it put in a decent performance in Cheapism's two budget beer taste-offs, occupying third place in the craft category in both sessions.
When stacked against three other craft brews and five American-style lagers in the 2016 competition, Samuel Adams Boston Lager was deemed good but not great by our review panel. The "middle of the road" mildness and "bitter, but not too bitter" end satisfied most of the seven tasters. Others enjoyed the underlying flavors of "malt, hops, and flowers" and the brew's "extended finish." Two of the panelists called Sam Adams one of their favorites, while others gave it an average rating of 5 out of 10.
Expert reviewers are more enthusiastic about Sam Adams Boston Lager than our two tasting panels. A certified beer judge at The Beer Connoisseur awarded it 92 points, or an overall rating of 18 out of 20, and warmed to its notes of caramel and toast and its substantial, silky head. An editor from Wine Enthusiast magazine gave the brew an impressive 91 points, calling it a "classic" in her review.
Mid- to low-cost for a craft beer, a six-pack of 12-ounce bottles was $8.99 on sale ($9.99 regular price) at the local supermarket. This averages out to about 12 cents an ounce, or just under 14 cents an ounce at regular price. The ABV is 4.9 percent.
Whether your assessment of Sam Adams Boston Lager meshes with the experts or our review panel, this tried-and-true craft brew remains a solid choice and a decent value.