Best Price-Matching Policies
Published on By Louis DeNicola
The idea behind price matching seems simple: You see that a store is advertising a sale on an item you want but you'd rather buy somewhere else -- maybe someplace closer to home, where you'll already be shopping anyway. Instead of driving the extra miles, you approach a nearby store with a price-match policy and offer to buy the item there if you can pay the lower price. Win-win, right? The retailer gets your business and you get the price you want. If only it were really that simple. Even the best price-match policies are rife with rules and exclusions. Each retailer's policy is different and ignoring the fine print can lead to frustration and wasted time.
Target Price-Match Policy
Target has announced that it will match prices from 29 online retailers, including Amazon, in addition to local competitors. Although you'll need to wait in the customer service line to request a price match, the policy is clear, easy to follow, and a winner in our book. The store's practice of applying manufacturer coupons after matching, rather than before, makes for greater savings.
Lowe's Price-Match Policy
The Lowe's guarantee, which covers local competitors and their websites, comes with an extra 10 percent off if you find a lower price somewhere else. The home improvement retailer automatically gives online shoppers the lower of the Lowes.com and Lowe's in-store prices with store pickup or local delivery. Lowe's gives customers a full 30 days after purchase to find a lower price on an appliance and claim a refund for the difference.
Best Buy Price-Match Policy
Best Buy matches prices advertised by local competitors, a half-dozen online stores such as Amazon, and its own website. However, it allows a relatively strict 15 days for post-purchase price adjustments, which are granted only when Best Buy lowers its own prices. Return and rebuy, you say? Not so fast. Taking back too many items can get you temporarily banned from making any returns, even if you have a receipt.
Home Depot Price-Match Policy
Home Depot offers a price-match-plus-10-percent-off policy that applies to local competitors. But ineligible appliances and no explicit provision for price adjustment after purchase keep the home improvement retailer from claiming one of the best price-match policies. An insider tip points to possible savings from helpful store employees, who have the power to give discounts even without a competitor's ad to match.
Walmart Price-Match Policy
A store already well known for low-prices, Walmart will match prices on a variety of items, including food -- even online for select competitors. But consumer complaints are prevalent online. It seems many store employees don't know the rules or simply don't follow them. Technically you don't need to have a print copy of the competitor's ad with you, but bring one along, if you can, to avoid a hassle.
JC Penney Price-Match Policy
JC Penney's policy applies only to local competitors but is very lenient when it comes to returns and post-purchase price adjustment. The company also seems to give store managers a decent amount of leeway. For instance, a supervisor might match a price you show on your mobile phone, even though it's technically against policy.
Sears Price-Match Policy
On the positive side, Sears will match online prices from websites associated with nearby stores, as long as those retail stores honor their own online prices. But unlike other retailers that match websites, Sears asks that you print out the order page and factors in shipping and handling charges, rather than matching the subtotal.
Kohl's Price-Match Policy
Kohl's requires shoppers to bring in a print ad from a local competitor; won't match Kohls.com prices, much less other online prices; and won't let customers use coupons if they request a price match. A number of online reports and our own experience reveal that employees often don't know about the price-matching policy.
A Frugal Shopper's Guide to Price-Matching Policies
We examined eight popular stores that price match, from department stores to home improvement centers, with the goal of identifying the best price-match policies and the ones that may not be worth the effort. Two retailers topped our list: Target has expanded its Low Price Promise to 29 online stores, including Amazon, and Lowe's not only matches competitors' prices but throws in an extra 10 percent discount. A few other retailers have similar guarantees that don't quite measure up to the best price-match policies. Best Buy, for example, followed Target's lead in matching online prices but has limited the list to a handful of retailers. Although Home Depot mirrors Lowe's 10-percent-off guarantee, it's limited to regular retail prices, whereas Lowe's matches discounted prices. Walmart's guarantee is admirably clear but less lenient in practice than on paper. Although JC Penney's open-ended policy gives managers broad authority to grant customers lower prices, it's likely to be inconsistently applied. Sears and Kohl's are the least permissive retailers we researched.
We compared the retailers on a number of fronts, from basic policy exclusions to employee attitudes toward price matching. We read feedback posted online by customers around the country and paid visits to the stores to see how they apply their guarantees in practice. All the price-match policies seem to have some rules in common: Price matching is allowed only for identical items and closeout prices are excluded, to name a couple. But other important factors, such as which competitors a store will match and what kind of proof you need of a competitor's price, vary among stores. Most chains let customers request a price match even after the fact (if they find a better deal) but provide different time frames for such adjustments.
When you request a price match, you generally expect to pay the lowest price you can find at the store that's most convenient for you. Retailers are often willing to oblige, even if it means a little less profit, in order to acquire loyal customers and reinforce an image as a low-price destination. But as we illustrate in this guide, not all price-matching policies are created equal and some common exclusions may catch consumers off guard. Official rules are also inconsistently applied in practice. Keeping up with the best price-matching policies can empower frugal shoppers, guaranteeing they get the best deals possible without driving around to every store in town.
Price-Match Guarantees: The Fine Print
Most price-match guarantees come with lists of exclusions and vague, ill-defined terms such as "qualifying product" and "local retail competitor." These can make it difficult for consumers to get a store to honor what appears to be a straightforward policy. In many cases, it seems, the final decision is left to employees' discretion.
Eligible Items.The pesky word "identical" crops up in nearly every low-price guarantee. A string of comments on a post on Elliot.org, a consumer advocacy blog, reveals how companies use the term to deny would-be price matchers. Large retailers have enough buying power with manufacturers that they often request unique model numbers for expensive items such as mattresses, electronics, and appliances. One commenter bought a TV at Walmart and requested the retailer match a cheaper price on what looked like the same TV at Best Buy. The Walmart clerk didn't even bother to compare the ad and receipt the customer brought in because any TV would have had a model number specific to the retailer. Likewise, consumer goods may come in slightly different size packages or carry store brand names. Items such as Target's Market Pantry food, Sears' Kenmore appliances, and Home Depot's Husky tools do not qualify for price matching.
Eligible Merchants.Although some retailers don't clearly define what qualifies as a competitor, price-match guarantees generally require that the price to be matched come from a retailer with brick-and-mortar stores; only Target, Walmart, and Best Buy include select online-only merchants in their low-price guarantees.
The competing store also must be located nearby, but what exactly qualifies as local is up for debate. Target's policy states that the store must be in the same "market area," which could mean a city, metro area, or rural region. However, in a comment on Elliot.org, a Target shopper writes of being denied a price match because the ad came from a Toys R Us store that was only a mile away but in a different ZIP code. Best Buy gives more precise a 25-mile radius. Lowe's uses the "local retailer" phrase without any more specific definition; it seems the ultimate decision is up to the clerk or store manager. Sears has an equally broad "reasonable distance" qualifier and a somewhat odd policy for online prices: It will match a price on a website associated with a local retail store, but only if the store matches its own online prices.
Other Exclusions.Myriad other restrictions keep consumers from compelling retailers to match lower prices. One common requirement is that the competitor's ad must clearly show the final discounted price of an item. It can't merely say 20 percent off, for example, or buy one get one half off. Price-match guarantees also don't usually apply to competitor clearance sales, limited-time offers, going-out-of-business sales, or discounts on damaged or open-box items. Many stores specifically exclude ads for the days around Thanksgiving and create dedicated Black Friday price-match policies.
Most price-match guarantees exclude prices that require a loyalty card, common at large drugstores and supermarkets such as CVS and Albertsons. A shopper posting on Pissed Consumer gripes that Walmart refuses to match ads from Albertsons when sale prices there are advertised as membership rewards. Consumers may also run into trouble if an item is out of stock at either store or must be special ordered. Several people mention this online with regard to Home Depot, which promises an additional 10 percent off competitors' prices. One consumer who posted on a Fat Wallet forum requested a price match after finding a washer and dryer listed for less in an ad from a nearby store. The retailer matched the price but wouldn't give the extra 10 percent off because the appliances technically weren't in stock at Home Depot; the floor models were only displays and the washer and dryer would be delivered from a nearby warehouse. The thing is, all the store's appliances were "out of stock" by that definition. Yet large signs above the display models advertised Home Depot's price-match-plus-10-percent-off guarantee.
How to Price Match
If you're wondering exactly how to price match, it's pretty straightforward: Most of the stores we researched authorize cashiers to match competitors' advertised prices right at checkout. In most cases, if you've brought a print ad with you and it meets all the requirements, the clerk working the register can easily match the price on the spot. Some stores also accept a copy or picture of the ad or an ad you've found online and printed out or displayed on your smartphone, although others specifically prohibit these substitutes. Shoplocal collects circulars from all the stores we researched and lets shoppers search for the weekly ads for their local area. The clerk may call to verify the competitor's price, which takes a little time but is still relatively easy.
Walmart's ad-match guarantee states that customers don't even need to have an ad with them, in any form, to request that the retailer match a competitor's price. However, employees at four different Walmarts told us that customers not only need to present the ad, it must be a print ad; photos or copies won't be accepted. A customer service manager at a fifth store offered an alternative view of the policy: Strictly speaking, if you know of a competitor that is offering a lower price, a Walmart representative can call the store to verify it. But bringing in a print ad as proof of the lower price is recommended to avoid the hassle. In general, if there's a dispute over the fine print, you may find yourself having to wait for a supervisor. Kohl's requires that a supervisor be called over to approve any price adjustment.
At Target, alone among the stores we researched, prices cannot be matched at the register; shoppers must visit the customer service desk to get special authorization. Luckily there weren't many people waiting for help when we were redirected to guest services. On past visits to the store, however, we've noticed long, slow-moving lines, as have customers reviewing Target's low-price guarantee online. Then again, the customer service line may be shorter than the lines at the registers. And even if the line is long, the opportunity to pay Amazon prices offline and apply coupons on top of a price match may make the wait worthwhile.
Employee Discretion.After closely reading a number of ad-match guarantees and speaking with numerous store representatives over the phone and in person, we've come to realize that price matching often comes down to an employee's discretion. Several policies we examined are surprisingly short, which leaves room for interpretation -- and for confusion. The Kohl's policy runs only a few sentences, for example, but when we put it to the test, we discovered some unwritten rules in response to common questions: Would a picture on a phone suffice as a copy of the competitor's ad? Do membership stores such as Costco count as competitors? Can customers use coupons after they're granted a price match? The answers, according to a customer service rep, are no, no, and no again. On Pissed Consumer, when a shopper complained that Kohl's wouldn't match a discounted price because the competitor's ad listed a different starting price for the item than Kohl's, current and former Kohl's employees responded differently in the comments: One would have approved the match, because the products were clearly the same, and the other said the store was right not to match the price in this case.
Even companies that clearly address such issues in the fine print online give employees a little bit of leeway -- and sometimes that can work in consumers' favor. A shopper who posted on a Best Buy forum was looking to have the cost of a camera lowered by $200 to match a local competitor and called customer service to make the request before heading to the store. The first person who answered denied the match; the second approved it. A commenter pointed out that technically the situation didn't meet certain requirements in Best Buy's guarantee, but the retailer seems to allow customer representatives some discretion in order to keep from losing business.
While consumers appreciate such flexibility, it can also breed inconsistency. In comments on a Hip2Save post, a couple of Walmart shoppers say cashiers seem to apply the seemingly straightforward policy irregularly, matching prices one week but not the next; on milk but not on bread or produce. In cases like this, it can help to know the main points of the fine print and maybe bring a copy of the ad-match guarantee with you, especially if you have your eye on an expensive product. At some stores -- JC Penney, for example -- the policy is posted at the registers for reference. Generally store managers follow the rules, although some have their own interpretations.
Online Price Matching
As consumers have become more comfortable shopping online and more conscious of the lower prices often found at low-overhead online shops, some brick-and-mortar stores have tried to stay competitive by venturing into online price matching. The policies at Target, Walmart, and Best Buy even include online-only merchants such as Amazon. This is a win-win for consumers, who can pay the same low price they would online without having to wait or pay for shipping. We used Amazon's iPhone app to scan a Sonicare toothbrush and got Target to lower the price by $30. (The only thing this doesn't account for is sales tax, which Amazon and other Internet retailers aren't required to collect in most states, although that may change soon and consumers are supposed to pay when they file their state tax returns.)
Experts see these policy changes as a reaction to the trend of "showrooming." Consumers who take advantage of lower prices online still want to be able to check things out in person before they buy, so they watch HDTVs and try digital cameras in stores but make their final purchases online, where the products are cheaper. Online price matching is a bid to transform showrooming browsers into paying customers by providing some assurance they're getting a good deal.
Best Buy has had a particular problem with showrooming. As reported in The New York Times, the retailer went as far as replacing standard barcodes with Best Buy-exclusive barcodes in stores to prevent shoppers from scanning products with an app to look up competitors' prices. The retailer's low-price guarantee extends to online prices at Amazon, B&H Photo Video, Crutchfield, Dell.com, HP.com, Newegg, and TigerDirect. The online price matching policies at Walmart and Target include about 30 major e-commerce sites. Best Buy, Target, and Walmart also promise to match prices displayed on their own websites. That's right -- the same item might cost less on Target.com than at your local Target store. Prices at retail stores are generally a little higher because expenses such as staffing, utilities, and insurance, not to mention rent, all drive up the cost of offline transactions.
Other retailers, such as Lowe's, also offer online price matching, but it's limited to local competitors' websites and the companies' own online storefronts; the guarantees do not apply to online-only merchants. Shoppers who order an item online from Lowes.com for in-store pickup or local delivery are automatically be charged the lower of the online and in-store prices, without having to request a price match. Sears will match prices on competitors' websites, but only for retailers that honor their own online prices in-store (a manager may call the competitor to verify its policy).
There are a number of smartphone apps, including RedLaser, ShopSavvy, and the Amazon app, that can help consumers check competitors' prices as they shop. Online price matching may be worth a try even if you're shopping someplace where the guarantee doesn't explicitly cover it. When we went into a JC Penney, where the policy states that all online and mobile pricing is excluded, the manager said he'd accept a price we showed him on our phone from another department store, although he'd consider calling the local store to verify it. The companies' own websites are almost always worth a look, as well. Although many retailers won't match their own online prices, all the stores we researched except Kohl's provide free pickup at the nearest retail location, so you can order online if you find a lower price.
Thus far we've discussed the concept of price matching mainly with the idea that you'd walk into a store and ask the clerk (or customer service rep) to match a lower price from a competitor before you buy. But retailers generally extend the same price-matching terms beyond the purchase date, allowing customers to claim what is often referred to as a price adjustment. At Sears, for example, if you find a lower price on a product you've purchased, you have 14 days to return with the ad and be reimbursed the difference. At Best Buy, the price-adjustment period used to be as long as 60 days, but since the retailer added price matching for online stores, it has also narrowed the return and exchange window to just 15 days. Even more limiting, refunds are awarded only if Best Buy itself lowers the price within the 15-day window, not if the customer finds a lower price from a competitor.
JC Penney doesn't give a time frame for price adjustment; it merely says the ad from the competitor must still be valid. Company representatives told us it's ultimately up to the manager's discretion. Other retailers, such as Home Depot, match prices only at the time of purchase, although their policies don't explicitly say so, as an NBC News/Today Money post points out. Lowe's, the other home improvement store we researched, has a generous 30-day window for appliances.
Of course, shoppers can always return and rebuy an item, but it's best not to make a habit of doing so. Many stores track returns, and if you've made too many, you may be denied or temporarily banned from making a return or exchange. The Hartford Courant tells the story of one Best Buy customer who was told he would be allowed no returns or exchanges for 90 days. It turned out Best Buy had used his driver's license to monitor his return/exchange behavior via a California-based company called The Retail Equation. Although it's intended to keep consumers from abusing store policies, it appears to have disrupted the lives of honest shoppers as well. The customer from the Courant column told the paper that several of his returns came after Christmas and he had receipts for all of them. Although the company does not publicize which stores use its system, other reports indicate that Home Depot is also among the retailers that have signed up for the service.
A post on Slickdeals suggests that the system's connection to price matching may go beyond returning and rebuying. After being denied a return at Best Buy, the poster requested a report from The Retail Equation to see what kind of activity may have raised a red flag. The list included six transactions, four of which were price matches.
After a bit of back-and-forth, The Retail Equation told us that price matches typically aren't counted as returns, but retailers can choose to incorporate such transactions into their data, and some point-of-sale systems don't distinguish among price matches, returns, and exchanges. The good news is that Best Buy doesn't require identification for price matching during the initial purchase, so it doesn't seem to be tracking that, at least. If you are asked for ID, it may be wise to decline if you can. The Retail Equation also told us it doesn't share customer data among stores. Therefore, activity at Home Depot shouldn't get a shopper suspended from making returns at Best Buy, for example.
Familiarizing yourself with the various retailers' policies and practices can keep you from getting into a sticky situation. As we've seen, though, decisions are often made at the store level. Going in with a friendly approach, the requisite documentation, and a bit of optimism should make it easier to get stores to grant your requests.