Build Me Up (Peanut) Butter Cup
Peanut butter cups are a top-tier candy. You may think one brand in particular has the market cornered, but there are plenty of other brands who have thrown their cups into the ring. We tasted all the versions we could find, including tons of Reese's varieties, a low-sugar brand, and options from Aldi and Trader Joe's, comparing them on the quality of the chocolate, flavor and texture of the filling, and ratio of chocolate to PB. We've ranked them all from forgettable to crave-worthy, starting with our winner, a cup that comes with its own cult following.
Prices and availability are subject to change.
Related: We Tried 13 Kinds of Chocolate and These Are the Best